Can Viewing Art Provide Emotional Insight & Catalyze Healing?

Take a look at this article by Dr. Jeremy Spiegel that considers whether viewing artwork in a gallery setting may lay the groundwork towards self-understanding.

I originally posted this on the Liz Beck Designs facebook page on 07/11, and recieved this question from Cathy Malchiodi:

“Gosh Liz, what do you really think about this?”

My response:

“You know, I’ve been seeing a lot of articles lately talking about art therapy in the context of going to a museum and viewing artwork, but usually for the Alzheimer’s/dementia population. I’m not familiar with research done on the effectiveness of treating a mental illness through the viewing of art. If you know of any, Cathy, I’d love to read it!

In any case, when I read Dr. Spiegel’s post, I couldn’t help but think how collage images are used in art therapy sessions. The images are created by someone other than the person choosing to use them in a collage; the images are chosen because they resonate in some way with the client and are a source of exploration throughout the therapeutic session. In this way, I can see how going to a gallery and focusing on pieces of artwork that stand out to the client could open up fruitful discussion and self-examination.

The method used to explore the images and the ego strength of the client would be key. For example, I wouldn’t bring a client who has a tendency to dissociate or have intense and difficult to contain emotional reactions to a public environment to view triggering images. I also wouldn’t want to have a discussion about a particular piece in the middle of the gallery, for other people to hear. Perhaps the art viewing would work best by having a client write down his or her impressions and experiences to later be explored in a private therapy session. I would also want to bring a picture of the artwork to the therapy session to help bring the client back to the original viewing experience.”

What are your thoughts?

AATA Conference Awards


Congratulations to Nancy Gerber, Ron Hayes (my old professors) and Myra Levick for their awards at this year’s AATA conference. I wish I could’ve been there to extend my best wishes in person!

Why We Need the Arts in Medicine

Check out this article by Gary Christenson, M.D., on the value of including the arts in both medical education and healthcare in general.

Here’s a break down of the main topics:

1. Studying the arts makes medical students into better doctors

2. The arts have therapeutic benefits

3. The arts can help prevent disease

4. The arts can improve the patient experience

5. The arts can promote physician well-being

Hat tip— the Art Therapy Alliance on Twitter.

This Week’s News—Recap

As promised, here’s a recap of the art therapy news of the week…plus some other interesting tidbits sprinkled in!

  • Imagine Technology As An Ocean
  • Guitar Villa music, art therapy program targets mental health needs
  • Facing Alzheimer’s: Art Therapy and Alzheimer’s
  • Therapist’s film tells inspiring story
  • Photographic Education Raises $10,000 in donations for Akron Children’s Hospital
  • The Hidden Village Behind Golden Gate Fields
  • Being a hero to a cause prompts site dedication
  • Social networking ‘utopia’ isn’t coming
  • Telemedicine is giving Idaho patients health care from a distance
  • Ten ways to heal yourself with art
  • Do Antidepressants Make You Sad?
  • Want More Art Therapy News?

    Be sure to follow me on either Facebook or Twitter. I’m posting art therapy related news stories on a daily basis! And, for those who don’t have a Facebook or Twitter account, I intend to post a weekly recap here on my blog :)

    Thank you for your support!

    Linehan Talks About Her Personal Struggle With Mental Illness

    Marsha Linehan—NYT

    Marsha Linehan—NYT

    This is a must read article about Marsha Linehan‘s struggle with mental illness. For those of you unfamiliar with Linehan’s work, she is the founder of Dialectical Behavioral Therapy, possibly most effective therapeutic treatment for Borderline Personality Disorder available today.

    Marsha Linehan arrived at the Institute of Living on March 9, 1961, at age 17, and quickly became the sole occupant of the seclusion room on the unit known as Thompson Two, for the most severely ill patients. The staff saw no alternative: The girl attacked herself habitually, burning her wrists with cigarettes, slashing her arms, her legs, her midsection, using any sharp object she could get her hands on…

    “I was in hell,” she said. “And I made a vow: when I get out, I’m going to come back and get others out of here.”

    What Is It About Art That Can Potentially Cause Harm?

    Shared by Dr. Laura Dessauer via the Art Therapy Alliance on LinkedIn.

    This article, found in the International Journal of Art Therapy, is an excellent reminder that although using art therapeutically may seem straight forward, it isn’t. Art making is powerful and reaches parts of oneself that may have been unconscious, semiconscious and defended away. Therefore, when therapists or therapeutic programs incorporate art into their practice with little training they may not realize they are exposing their clients to the risk of doing more harm than good.

    Abstract:

    The notion of arts-based risk is rarely acknowledged outside of art therapy. This paper describes an injury sustained as a result of art activity. The case was subject to legal proceedings which established arts practitioner and organisational negligence. The case was consequently settled out of court for a large sum. The paper reports the legal argument and explores what the process tells us about how art can both help and harm participants. This specifically concerns the power of art to make the subjective seem real and the need for practitioners to able to competently assess participants’ psychological vulnerability to this. The case represents an important milestone in the current arts and health debate, particularly with regard to the protection of the public. Lessons to be learnt for organisations seeking to deliver arts and health projects to vulnerable people are discussed.

    Springham, Neil (2008) ‘Through the eyes of the law: What is it about art that can harm people?’, International Journal of Art Therapy, 13:2, 65 – 73